Sales consultant Felix
"The 183-day rule is for employees. Tax residence in Germany depends on a home and on continuous stays."
Learn how Felix worked from changing locations through a US LLC for years and how we pinned down his German tax liability to the day.
Background
Felix advises mid-sized companies on building up their sales. Since 2021 he has worked from changing locations, a few months in Asia, then back in Europe and, in between, longer stays with his family in Germany. He invoices through a single-member LLC in the US. No tax is due on this there. He had not filed anything in Germany because he did not consider himself taxable anywhere. He now lives in South America, and before the move he wanted to know whether anything from the past years was still open.
Felix's Main Goals
Felix wanted legal certainty about the past, meaning whether and for which years he should have paid tax in Germany. Any open issues were to be resolved before he settles permanently in South America. He also wanted to know what to watch out for in the years after that.
Challenges
Many people assume that 183 days decide where they are taxable. That rule applies to employees, though. Whether someone is fully taxable in Germany depends on whether they have a home here that they can use at any time, or whether they stay here for more than six months in a row. Short trips do not interrupt that period.
Then there was the LLC. In Germany a single-member LLC is usually treated like a partnership, so its profits are attributed directly to Felix, as if he were a sole trader. He had not kept records of his travel and income over the years.
The Solution
Instead of filing returns for every year as a precaution, we examined each year separately. That way Felix only had to file for the periods in which he was actually taxable. For the remaining years we set out in writing why there was no tax liability.
Actions Taken
Using flight data, bookings and account transactions, we reconstructed every day since 2021 and assessed his stays under section 9 of the German Fiscal Code. We also checked whether the flat at his family's home counts as a residence under section 8 and classified the LLC as transparent under German law. We calculated the profit for the taxable periods, and the income before that was taken into account under the progression clause. The returns went to the tax office with a detailed cover letter. We also filed the section 138 notification as a precaution.
Results
Felix was fully taxable in Germany for about a year and a half. For all other years it is documented that there was no tax liability. The late returns reached the tax office before it got in touch, and the additional tax was small.
One rule that many people do not know about matters for the future. A German citizen who moves to a low-tax country can remain taxable in Germany on certain income for several years. Felix knows this and can plan his next years accordingly.
Conclusion
Working from anywhere does not mean being taxable nowhere. For Felix, the careful analysis of his travel data made the difference. He had to file for about a year and a half instead of the whole period since 2021. If you travel a lot and come back to Germany regularly, keep a running record of your stays, because reconstructing them later is far more work.
Details changed to protect the client.
